Better there
Cancel flows and 15 retries, on the $99 plan
Personalized cancellation flows and smart dunning with 15 retries are $99 plan lines. Appfox retries failed cards on a schedule you cannot edit in the admin.
Loop is free for 50 active subscriptions, with a mobile portal, customer alerts, and growth analytics on that plan. The $99 plan adds 1% and names fixed bundles, build-a-box, widget templates, a branded portal with upsells, dunning with 15 retries, and cancellation flows. The $399 plan adds 0.75%, a dedicated manager, 24×7 Slack, gamified journeys, prepaid, and APIs. The listing is 5.0 from 781 reviews. Klaviyo and Omnisend are both named. Appfox is free for new installs with no subscriber cap and 0% of renewals, and it does not have Loop's cancel-flow builder or a 15-retry control. If those retention tools are why you are shopping, Loop is the better fit.
Better there
Personalized cancellation flows and smart dunning with 15 retries are $99 plan lines. Appfox retries failed cards on a schedule you cannot edit in the admin.
Better there
Fixed bundles and build-your-own are on the $99 plan, not the free plan. Appfox includes both on the free install. Loop still wins if you want those offers next to their cancel flows and a 781-review listing.
Better there
Loop's Works with line names both. Appfox documents both in the product docs. This one is a tie. Gorgias is on Loop's list and not on ours.
Better there
Fifty active subscriptions, then $99 or $399. The free plan does not pretend to include bundles or cancel flows. That honesty is useful when you are pricing the upgrade.
Not yet
The $399 plan names gamified subscriber journeys and rewards. Our rewards are a discount, gift, or free shipping after N paid cycles. There is no game layer.
Not yet
Loop names that on the $399 plan, with a dedicated manager. We include live chat and email, not a 24×7 Slack channel.
Not yet
We do ship prepaid. Their help center describes paying up front for several deliveries. The App Store listing puts that on the $399 plan. We do not ship their prepaid-plus-gifts package or the admin API.
Not yet
The self-serve import is an Appstle export. Loop is not named, and there is no Recharge file import. Do not assume a Loop file drops in.
| Feature | AppfoxFree | LoopFree to 50 subs |
|---|---|---|
| Price for a new installApp bill only. Shopify Payments is separate. | Free for new installs | Free, then $99 or $399 |
| Cut of each renewal | 0% | 1% on $99; 0.75% on $3995 |
| Cap on the cheap plan | No subscriber cap | 50 active subscriptions |
| Shopify App Store rating | 5.0 · 1 review | 5.0 · 781 reviews |
| Built for Shopify badge | No | No |
| Shopify checkoutSelling plans on Shopify checkout, not a separate checkout. | Yes | Yes |
| Customer portal | via Shopify customer accounts | On the free plan |
| Storefront languages on the listing | 9, including English | English; multilingual on the $399 plan |
| Free trial of the app | No trial. The install is free. | 14 days on paid plans |
| App Store launch | 10 September 2026 | 27 July 2021 |
| Annual app bill | No app bill for new installs | The public plans are monthly |
| Feature | AppfoxFree | LoopFree to 50 subs |
|---|---|---|
| Percent or fixed subscriber discount | Percent or fixed amount | Dynamic discounts in the overview |
| More than one frequency on a plan | Yes | Several frequencies on one selling plan |
| Lower price for the first cyclesNot the same as a $0 trial. | Intro price, then the normal discount | Discount can change after the first order |
| $0 trial for the shopper | No | 100% off the first order, then full price |
| Prepaid (pay once, deliver several times) | Yes | Pay up front for several deliveries. The listing puts it on the $399 plan. |
| Retry a failed payment | Yes. Schedule is fixed.6 | Up to 15 retries on the $99 plan |
| Block cancel until N orders | Per plan, customer portal only | Minimum orders before cancel |
| Bill on set days of the week or month | Yes | Anchor day, with a cutoff window |
| Extra discount after N paid cycles | Up to two tiers on a plan | Rewards on the $399 plan |
| Existing subscribers keep their priceOn Appfox, Shopify stores the contract price. Editing the plan does not reprice old subscribers. | via Shopify | Automatic price updates on the $99 plan |
| Create a subscription from the admin | For phone or in-person sales | From the admin |
| Feature | AppfoxFree | LoopFree to 50 subs |
|---|---|---|
| Pause and resume | Yes | Yes |
| Cancel | Switch you can turn off | Cancel flows on the $99 plan |
| Skip the next order | Docs disagree1 | With a cap on consecutive skips |
| Swap a product | Yes | Portal preference |
| Change frequency | Yes | When that selling plan is on in the portal |
| Change the next order date | Yes | With a maximum number of days |
| Update the card | Yes | Yes |
| Add or remove a product | Yes | Add a one-time item |
| Apply a discount code | Yes | Including more than one code |
| Change the shipping address | Email exists; switch not documented2 | Yes |
| Passwordless or magic-link login | via Shopify customer accounts | Email magic link, or Shopify accounts |
| Multi-step cancel flow | No | On the $99 plan |
| Feature | AppfoxFree | LoopFree to 50 subs |
|---|---|---|
| Subscribe widget on the product page | Theme styling, no code | Templates on the $99 plan |
| Fixed bundle (you pick the products) | One price for the set | Fixed bundles on the $99 plan |
| Build-a-box (they pick the products) | Min and max, on the free install | On the $99 plan |
| Add-ons at subscription checkout | Yes | Portal upsell on the $99 plan |
| Reward after N paid orders | Percent, amount, fixed price, free gift, or free shipping | Rewards on the $399 plan |
| Subscription boxes | Fixed bundles and build-a-box | In the overview |
| Feature | AppfoxFree | LoopFree to 50 subs |
|---|---|---|
| Transactional subscription emails | 14 templates, each can be turned off | Customer alerts on the free plan |
| Analytics dashboard | Active, paused, cancelled, failed, AOV, next 7 days | On the free plan |
| Billing reports you can export | Success, failed, queued, skipped | Order, churn, and inventory reports |
| KlaviyoCompetitor yes means Klaviyo is named under Works with. | Lifecycle events, private API key | Yes |
| Omnisend | Same style of lifecycle events as Klaviyo | Yes |
| Feature | AppfoxFree | LoopFree to 50 subs |
|---|---|---|
| Help moving subscribers from another appPayment methods saved in Shopify come across. Cards held outside Shopify need customers to add them again. Seal can move some cards from Stripe, Braintree, Authorize.net, or PayPal Express. | Appstle import keeps Shopify-saved cards. Recharge is with our help.8 | ? Not confirmed.9 |
| Shopify FlowYes means the listing's Works with line names Flow. Loop's own Flows product is a separate tool. | On the listing, not in the integrations docs3 | ? Not confirmed.9 |
| Sell a subscription on Shopify POS | POS tile, Shopify Payments, POS 10.15+ | ? Not confirmed.9 |
| API for your own tools | External API and MCP, on the free install | Admin and storefront APIs on the $399 plan |
| Gorgias | No | Yes |
| Zapier | Yes | Pause, skip, or reschedule from a Zap |
| SMS | No | Through Attentive or Postscript |
| Feature | AppfoxFree | LoopFree to 50 subs |
|---|---|---|
| Support promise on the listing | Live chat and email. Not 24/7. | 24×7 Slack on the $399 plan |
| Hands-on setup | Listing says white-glove. File import is Appstle only.8 | Dedicated CSM on the $399 plan |
| Stores already paying the app | Old paid plans stay until you change them | Percent fee on paid plans |
| Sensible while you are small | Free install, no subscriber cap | Free for 50 active subscriptions |
| Sensible at a large subscriber base | Still $0 today. One public review. | $399 plan plus 0.75% |
| Public proof on 10 Oct 2026 | 1 review, no badge | 781 reviews, no badge |
| One-click checkout links | Variant and selling plan. Optional email and Shop Pay. | On the $99 plan |
| Inventory forecast | No | Projected quantity in Analytics |
Appfox column checked against the product on 10 October 2026. Loop checked against public docs the same day. A question mark means those pages do not say.
Sources
Full comparison table with Recharge, Appstle, Seal, Loop, and Skio.
For a free install with no 50-subscriber cap, a portal, Klaviyo, Omnisend, and build-a-box included, yes. It is not a Loop alternative if the cancel flows or the 15-retry dunning are the reason you would pay $99.
The free plan lists 50 active subscriptions, a mobile portal, customer alerts, and analytics. Bundles, the widget templates, dunning controls, and cancellation flows are on the $99 plan, which also adds a 1% fee.
The $99 plan says 1% and 0¢. The $399 plan says 0.75% and 0¢. The free plan's feature list does not mention a fee.
Yes. Loop's column is the public help center on 10 October 2026. We say they win on cancel flows, dunning controls, and a clearer paid ladder. Cells we could not confirm are question marks.
Free for new installs, 0% of renewals, and a short list of things we do not do. One App Store review. If that is not enough proof, use the other column.
Free plan available · support@getappfox.com